ObjectiveTo assess the care needs of outpatients in stomatological hospital and provide evidence for the improvement of patients' satisfaction. MethodsAccording to the characteristics of outpatients in stomatological hospital, a convenience sample of 150 cases was assessed with care needs survey based on Kano Model between May 2011 to February 2012. ResultsAmong all the care needs, 6 were essential, 11 were expected, and 3 had an attractive quality. Essential and attractive care needs accounted for 70% of all items. In the quadrant chart analysis, there were 8 items in competitive advantage district and 12 in the urgent improvement district respectively. ConclusionKano model is a quality attributive recognition tool. Through the analysis of the questionnaire, we believe the hospital should improve such aspects as information disclosure, public facilities, appointment, optimization process, and shortening patients' waiting time, in order to meet patients' needs by providing them with high quality services.
ObjectiveTo explore the effect of "HIS" nursing service mode in promoting the quality of clinical nursing service for key specialties in the department of gastrointestinal surgery. MethodsIn the Department of Gastrointestinal Surgery, West China Hospital of Sichuan University, "HIS" nursing service mode was carried out on January 1, 2012.Questionnaires surveying hospitalized patients' satisfaction before (n=360, between January and December 2011) and after (n=360, between January and December 2012) the implementation of "HIS" nursing service mode were retrospectively compared and analyzed. ResultsThe patients' general satisfaction score was improved significantly from 83.27±5.71 to 97.92±6.23 after the implementation of "HIS" nursing service mode (t=-8.001, P < 0.05).For all the 14 items in the satisfaction questionnaire, the differences before and after the implementation had statistical significance (P < 0.05). ConclusionThe "HIS" nursing service mode can effectively improve patients' satisfaction of clinical nursing service for key specialties in the department of gastrointestinal surgery, and it is worthy of further promotion.
Objective To investigate the satisfaction of patients who signed up for chronic disease continuous health management services, so as to provide a theoretical basis for improving service quality. Methods We conducted an online anonymous survey by issuing an electronic questionnaire to all patients who met the inclusion criteria through the short message platform of the hospital from October 8th to 19th, 2021, and used χ2 test and logistic regression to compare the differences in satisfaction among different patients and explore the factors affecting satisfaction. Results A total of 3311 short messages were send out, and 816 valid copies of questionnaire were recalled. The total satisfaction was 77.3%, and the satisfaction before, during and after service were 86.0%, 75.2% and 73.7%, respectively. The items with low satisfaction included service pricing (58.9%), online follow-up (57.5%) and overall cost reduction (43.9%). There were significant differences in satisfaction among patients of different permanent addresses and health status (P<0.05). The multiple binary logistic regression analysis showed that the respondents in Chengdu city had lower satisfaction than those outside Sichuan province [odds ratio (OR)=0.377, 95% confidence interval (CI) (0.156, 0.908), P=0.030], and the respondents with poor, general, and good self-reported health status had lower satisfaction than those with very good self-reported health status [OR=0.196, 95%CI (0.067, 0.577), P=0.003; OR=0.165, 95%CI (0.058, 0.468), P=0.001; OR=0.317, 95%CI (0.108, 0.927), P=0.036]. Conclusions The patients’ satisfaction with chronic disease continuous health management services is at a high level. The next step should focus on service pricing and online follow-up, and strive to improve the service experience of people with low satisfaction.
Objective To evaluate the ambulatory surgery mode by using health economical mothods and provide reference for optimization and decision of surgical operation mode. Methods The patients who underwent unilateral flexible ureteroscopic holmium laser lithotriphy for ureteral calculi in Xiangya Hospital, Central South University between January 1st to December 31th, 2015 were selected in this study, including 59 with ambulatory surgery mode (the ambulatory group) and 65 with special in-hospital surgery mode (the special group). The differences in average bed occupancy time, cost, therapeutic effect, and satisfaction between the two operation modes were compared. Results The average bed occupancy time in the ambulatory group and the special group was (1.03±0.18) and (6.35±0.74) days, respectively, and the difference was statistically significant (P<0.05). The patients in both groups were followed up for one month after the operation, and the incidence of complications was 6.8% (4/59) in the ambulatory group and 6.2% (4/65) in the special group, without significant difference (P>0.05). The satisfaction score in the ambulatory group and the special group was 96.48±0.23vs. 96.53±0.18 without significant difference (P>0.05). The differences in direct medical cost [(17 738.28±1 027.85)vs. (21 307.67±554.41) yuan], direct non-medical cost [(103.39±18.25) vs. (630.76±78.90) yuan], indirect cost[ (266.93±47.12) vs. (1 640.44±190.55) yuan], and total cost [(18 128.10±1 037.76) vs. (23 558.29±619.20) yuan] between the ambulatory group and the special group were all statistically significant (P<0.05). The treatment effect index in the ambulatory group and the special group was 0.96 and 1.05, respectively; the cost-effect ratio was 18 883.44 and 22 436.47, respectively. Sensitivity analysis showed that the adjusted cost-effect ratio in the ambulatory group (16 629.64) was still lower than that in the special group (20 534.91). Conclusions The cost-effect ratio of ambulatory surgery mode is superior than that of special in-hospital surgery mode, and there is no obvious difference in patients satisfaction between the two modes. Ambulatory surgery mode can be recommended to patients who meet the indications of day surgery.
Objective To explore the postoperative satisfaction of patients with lumbar disc herniation after enhanced recovery after surgery and its related factors. Methods A total of 102 patients with lumbar disc herniation were selected and analyzed by convenient sampling method from September 2016 to June 2017. The patients’ general information, functional status [using the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) to investigate the preoperative, postoperative and post-discharge ODI] and patients’ satisfaction (1 month after the discharge) were collected. Results A total of 102 patients, including 62 males and 40 females, aged from 14 to 82 years with an average of (43.8±14.4) years were included in the study.The mean length of hospital stay was (6.61±2.49) days. The total score of patients’ satisfaction was 62.43±6.37, and the satisfaction degree was at the middle and high level. Postoperative and post-discharge ODIs were associated with patients’ satisfaction (rs=0.328, 0.452; P<0.05). Conclusions The postoperative satisfaction of patients with lumbar disc herniation after enhanced recovery after surgery should be further improved. The medical staff should pay attention to the recovery of postoperative function in order to improve the patients’ satisfaction.
Objective To understand the current situation of patient satisfaction management in public hospitals, and provide reference for improving the level of hospital satisfaction management and enhancing patients’ medical experience. Methods A questionnaire survey was conducted on public hospitals using a combination of purposive sampling and convenience sampling between May 2021 and March 2023. The survey covered the current situation of organizational support, institutional construction, human resource allocation, evaluation technology, evaluation process, work mode, assessment incentives, and effectiveness tracking in satisfaction management of public hospitals. Results A total of 101 hospitals were surveyed. Among them, 85 hospitals (84.2%) had formulated and issued satisfaction management measures, 37 hospitals (36.6%) had not set up independent satisfaction management departments, and only 27 hospitals (26.7%) had set up a dedicated budget for satisfaction management. 37 hospitals (36.6%) did not use online survey methods for satisfaction evaluation, and 14.9%, 21.8%, and 37.6% of hospitals did not include demographic information such as age, gender, and education level in the questionnaire design, respectively. 66 hospitals (65.3%) were used satisfaction evaluation results as the basic basis for evaluating department and employee performance, while only 25 hospitals (24.8%) had set up a satisfaction award for year-end evaluations. There were differences in the specialized budget for satisfaction management and the design of satisfaction survey questionnaires among hospitals of different levels (P<0.05). There were differences in whether different types of hospitals had dedicated personnel responsible for daily management work such as satisfaction evaluation, opinion collection, and assessment (P<0.05). Conclusions There are still shortcomings in the institutional construction, institutional setting, and resource investment of satisfaction management in public hospitals, which restrict its standardized and long-term development. The informationization and professionalism of satisfaction evaluation in public hospitals need to be improved, and construction needs to be strengthened to enhance data quality. The utilization and incentive mechanism of satisfaction evaluation results in public hospitals are insufficient, limiting their potential in improving service quality and employee motivation.
Objective To optimize the environment of outpatient clinics in large hospitals, facilitate the patients’ visits and improve the comprehensive management level. Methods From September to November 2015, 2 hospitals in each part of a provincial city (middle, east, west, north and south), a total of 10 hospitals were chosed by convenient sampling method. The forms, types and distribution of outpatient navigation service system were investigated and analyzed by using a self-designed questionnaire. Results There were a total of 14 forms of counseling-guide services in the 10 hospitals. Just 1 hospital provided all the 14 forms of counseling-guide services, and 2 hospitals provided 13 forms of counseling-guide services, which were relatively complete. While the other 7 large hospitals provided only 4 to 6 forms of counseling-guide services, which were relatively simple. Conclusion Qualified outpatient navigation service system can help patients to receive more effective treatment, optimize the environment, highlighting the modern hospital humanistic service and the concept of intelligent service and scientific management.
目的 调查医疗文书填写现状并探讨其对患者满意度之间的影响。 方法 2012年10月－12月以呼吸内科住院的患者为调查对象，调查其医疗文书完成情况，统计医疗文书缺项数目。同时参考国内外患者满意度研究，自制满意度调查表，调查患者对医务人员满意度；分析医疗文书缺项数目对患者满意度的影响。 结果 研究共纳入151例患者，共有126份医疗文书存在不同程度填写缺陷，占83.44%，平均缺项（11.58 ± 11.63）条。总体患者就医满意度为6.85分，与医疗文书缺项数目呈现负相关性（R=?0.602，P=0.001）。患者性别、年龄、文化程度、付费方式和住院天数与患者满意度无相关性。 结论 医疗文书缺项数目较多、完成质量不高。需要加强医务人员对于医疗文书完成质量的重视程度。
Objective To evaluate if performing thyroidectomy through small incision has any notable aesthetic impact on patients compared with larger incision. Methods Thirty consecutive patients underwent thyroidectomy were enrolled from March 2008 to June 2008 in this prospective randomized pilot study. The incision length was 6 cm in the small incision group and 9 cm in the larger incision group. After 3 years follow-up，the scar aesthetics were evaluated by patients and surgeons using the Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale （POSAS），Vancouver Scar Scale （VSS），respectively. Digital photographs about scars were taken and assessed by non-research related viewers. Results There were 13 cases who received scar aesthetic assessment in both groups. The demographic characteristics of both groups were comparative. The overall patients’ satisfactions for the small incision group and the larger incision group were （2.5±1.9） scores and （2.2±1.5）scores， respectively （P=0.55）. There were no significant differences in scar assessment scale score as for other scar assessment scales （including VSS score，PSAS score，and OSAS score） between the two groups. The evaluation of digital photographs about scars by non-research related viewers was no significant difference （P＞0.05）. Conclusion Larger cervical scar in thyroidectomy does not decrease patients’ satisfaction with their scar results.
Objective To understand the effect and influencing factors of humanistic care on improving the experience of inpatients. Methods Patients were collected from a third grade class A women’s and children’s hospital in June 2015 and June 2016, and their satisfaction was investigated by a third party. The service items of Inpatients Satisfaction Item Score Table in 2015 were analyzed. Appropriate intervention measures were taken to low-score items, such as humanistic knowledge training to all medical staff, improvement health guidelines, implementation of recycling process, carrying out high quality nursing interventions, and so on. The patients satisfaction survey results in 2016 were compared with those of 2015. Results In 2016, the total satisfaction rate (89.94%), and the average score of items ranked the top three (94.64±0.14), including the level of medical technology, medical ethics and the overall evaluation of doctor’s professional ehtics, medical communication and service attitude, were higher than those of 2015 (85.25, 90.86±1.53). The average score of items ranked the last three (89.25±9.21), including hospital ward, hospital environment (clean, quiet and safe), hospital meals and room service, and hospital food quality, was higher than that of 2015 (78.64±2.40). However, compared with the same period in the last year, the rank of hospital environment fell by two places. Conclusions Hardware conditions like physical environment have an important impact on the experience of hospital patients. However, humanistic care is the key factor to improve the patients’ inpatient experience and satisfaction.