To study the effect of the repair of rabbit articular cartilage defects by the composite of chondrogenic induction of autologous MSCs and autologous “two-phase” bone matrix gelatin (BMG). Methods Twentyfour healthy adult New Zealand rabbits weighing 2 to 3 kg were divided into group A, B and C with 8 in each. Autologous MSCsderived from group A were cultured in vitro and observed under inverted phase contrast microscope when enough cells through trypsinization transferring in vitro were obtained. Then the growth curves of 1, 3 and 5 passage culture of MSCs were drawn. The 3rd passage MSCs were induced into chondrogenic differentiation by adding TGF-β1 (10 ng/mL), IGF-1 (10 ng/mL) and vitamin C (50 ng/mL) in vitro. At 8 days after induction, the features of chondrocytes were observed under inverted phase contrast microscope, and immunohistochemical staining and Mallory staining were made. Getting out part of the il ium of group A and B, according to the method of Urist, the “two-phase” BMG was acquired. Chondrogenic induction of autologous MSCs was inoculated into the corresponding BMG to set up a composite of cell-carrier, and then it was observed through scanning electric microscope after 3 days of culture. The model of articular cartilage defects of rabbits was made: in group A, autologous cell-carriers were implanted; in group B, there only existed autologous BMG; in group C, there was nothing. At 8, 12 weeks after operation, the gross, HE staining and immunohistochemical staining were made, and grading scales were evaluated according to Wakitani histological grading method. Results Features of MSCs were as follows: the shape of primary cells was shotspindled and of passage cells was long. As to the growth curves of 1, 3 and 5 passage culture of MSCs, passage cells grew slowly for 3 days after being passaged and went into log-growth during the 3rd and the 7th days and into plateau later, but the 3rd passage cells grew best. Observation of MSCs after chondrogenic induction was performed: the shape of cells was ell iptical and the effect of induction was verified by the positive results of collagen type II, S-100 and Mallory staining. Under scanning electricmicroscope, the structure of BMG was good and cells were observed growing in it well. As far as repair of articular cartilage defects are concerned at 8, 12 weeks after transplantation, the defects in group A were repaired by the hyl ine-l ike tissue and the structures of the cartilage surface and normal cartilage were in integrity, and immunohistochemical staining of collagen type II was positive, while those in group B and C were repaired by the fibrous-l ike tissues and the surfaces were irregular. In Wakitanni histological score, at 8 weeks after operation, group A was (3.50 ± 1.51) points, group B was (10.00 ± 1.41) points and group C was (12.00 ± 0.93) points; at 12 weeks, group A was (1.13 ± 0.99) points, group B was (8.38±1.30) points, and group C was (10.13 ± 1.64) points. At different time points, group A was significantly better than group B and C, showing significant differences (P lt; 0.05). Conclusion Induced autologous MSCs and the composite with autologous “two-phase” BMG have the function to repair articular cartilage defects, and they are better than autologous BMG transplanted only or nothing transplanted.
Objective To study the effect of adenovirus bone morphogenetic protein 2 gene(Ad-BMP-2) transfer inducing mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) compounded with fibrin gel on repair of rabbit cartilage defect. Methods ①BMP-2 and collagen type Ⅱ in MSCs transferred by Ad-BMP-2 were examined by RT-PCR, aniline dyeing and immunohistochemical analysis in vitro. ②MSCs were cultured in fibrin gel for 9 days, and were examined with electron microscope. ③Fortytwo rabbits suffering from cartilage defect were divided into 3 groups:the defects were treated with Ad-BMP-2 transfer inducing MSCs compounded with fibrin in group A, with MSCs compounded with fibringel in group B and with no implants in group C as control. HE and aniline dyeing, immunohistochemical analysis and biomechanics study were carried out in the 4th, 8thand 12th weeks. Results ①The positive results were observed for BMP-2 and collagen type Ⅱ with RT-PCR on the 3rd day and 5th day respectively, being statisticallysignificant difference when compared with control group(P＜0.05). ②Ad-BMP-2 transfer inducing MSCs cultured in fibrin gel were positively stained by aniline dyeing and immunohistochemstry. ③The therapy effect of group A was better than that of the other two groups in histology, biochemistry and biomechanics, and the biomechanic and histological features of repaired cartilage were similar to those of the natural cartilage. Conclusion Ad-BMP-2 can induce the expressionof collagen type Ⅱ and mucopolysaccharide in MSCs by secreting BMP-2, and can reconstruct articular cartilage defects better when compounded with fibrin gel.
Objective To establ ish a porcine model of articular full-thickness cartilage defect characterized byremaining cartilage calcified zone on femoral trochlea, so as to provide a considerable and comparative control group forinvestigating repair effects of tissue engineered scaffolds in articular cartilage defects with cartilage calcified zone remaining.Methods The full-thickness cartilage column defects (6 mm in diameter, 0.2-0.5 mm in depth) without damage on calcifiedcartilage zone were made on the femoral trochlea in 9 clean-grade 6-month-old Guizhou mini pigs by standard cartilage-defectmakingsuites. Microscopical observation was performed after modeling. Scanning were made by 3.0T MRI at 4 weeks. Thengeneral observation, stereomicroscope, and histological staining were used to observe cartilage repair. Results All animals wereal ive. No infection of incisions or patellar dislocations occurred; they were able to walk with partial weight-bearing immediatelyafter surgery and could move freely without limp at 1 week. Obvious signal discontinuity in trochlea and subchondral bone couldbe observed in MRI, without deep signal change in defects surrounding. Microscopical observation showed a few repair tissueand petechia at base of the defect with clear boundary. Nearly intact calcified zone of cartilage and zonal collapse of subchondralbone in defects could be observed with stereomicroscope. Under common microscope, no chondrocytes was found in defects,as well as negative staining of fast green-safranin O and alcian blue. Under polarized microscope, the bottom of defects werefilled with a l ittle of fibrous tissue presenting continuous and b l ight-refraction by sirius red staining. Conclusion Theanimal model of articular full-thickness cartilage defect on femoral trochlea by standard cartilage-defect-making suites can beapplied for the research of cartilage disease in early human osteoarthritis and function of calcified cartilage zone in pig.
OBJECTIVE To investigate the possibility of repairing the cartilage cartilage defect with homogeneous chondrocytes combined with Pluronic. METHODS: Homogeneous cartilage chondrocytes of adult New Zealand rabbits were harvested and cultured in vitro, which were marked by 3H-TdR and mixed with Pluronic. The medial or lateral condyle defects were made (phi 4 mm, extending down to the calcified zone) in 20 rabbits. In the experimental group, the right defects were repaired by homogeneous chondrocytes combined with Pluronic; in the control group, the left defects were repaired by Pluronic only or were left un-repaired. The animals were sacrificed in the 4th, 8th and 16th weeks after operation respectively. The repair results were observed and the cell source of repair tissue was distinguished. RESULTS: In the experimental group, the cartilage defects were repaired by the cartilage-like tissue after 8 weeks of operation; the defects were completely filled with mature cartilage tissue, which integrated smoothly with articular cartilage 16 weeks later. In the control group, only a small amount fibrous tissues were seen on the surface of defects. Autoradiographic assessment showed that the repair cells came from the implants, but not from self-chondrocytes. CONCLUSION: It is a good way to repair articular cartilage defects with homograft of tissue engineering cartilage. It is a convenient method to mark with 3H-TdR to discriminate the resource of the repair cells.
Objective To investigate the effect of “two-phase” tissue engineered cartilage constructed by autologous marrow mesenchymal stem cells(MSCs) and allogeneic bone matrix gelatin(BMG) in repairing articular cartilage defects. Methods Thirty-twoNew Zealand white rabbits were involved in the experiment. “Two-phase” allogeneic BMG scaffold (one side of porous cancellous bone and the other side of cortical bone; 3 mm both in diameter and in thickness) was prepared from iliac bone and limb bone of 5 rabbits by sequentially chemical method. The MSCs wereseparated from 18 New Zealand white rabbits and induced to express chondrocyticphenotype. The chondrocyte precursor cells were seeded onto “two-phase” allogeneic BMG to construct tissue engineering cartilage. Masson’s trichrome staining, PAS staining and scanning electronic microscopic observation were carried out at 1, 3 and 5 weeks. The defects of full thickness articular cartilage(3 mm both in diameter and in depth) were made at both sides of femoral medial condyles in 27 rabbits(including 18 of separated MSCs and the remaining 9). The defects were repaired with the tissue engineered cartilage at the right side (group A, n=18), with BMG at the left side(group B, n=18), and without any implant at both sides in the remaining 9 rabbits as a control( group C, n=18). After 1, 3 and6 months, the 6 specimens of femoral condyles were harvested in 3 groups, respectively. Gross observation, Masson’s trichrome and Alcian blue staining, modified Wakitani scoring and in situ hybridization of collagen type Ⅱ were carried out to assess the repair efficacy of tissue engineered cartilage. Results The “two-phase” BMG consisted of the dense cortical part and the loose cancellous part. In cancellous part, the pore size ranged 100-800 μm, in which the chondrocyte precursor cells being induced from MSCs proliferated and formed the cell-rich cartilaginous part of tissue engineered cartilage. In cortical part, the pore size ranged 10-40 μm, on which the cells arranged in a layer and formed the hard part of subchondral bone. After 1 month of transplantation, the cartilage and subchondral bone were regenerated in group A; during observation, the regenerated cartilage graduallythinned, but defect was repaired and the structure of the articular surface ansubchondral bone was in integrity. In groups B and C, defects were not repaired, the surrounding cartilage of defect was abrased. According to the modified Wakitani scoring, the indexes in group A were significantly higher than those in group B and C(Plt;0.01) except the thickness of cartilage at 6 months. The positive cell rate of in situ hybridization for collagen type Ⅱ in group A was also higher than those in groups B and C(Plt;0.01). Conclusion “Two-phase” allogeneic BMG is a prospective scaffold for tissue engineered cartilage,which combines with autologous chondrocyte precursor cells induced from MSCs toconstruct the tissue engineering cartilage. The tissue engineered cartilage can repair defects of articular cartilage and subchondral bone.
Objective To compare biological characteristics between articular chondrocyte and meniscal fibrochondrocyte cultured in vitro andto investigate the possibility of using cultured cartilage as a substitute for meniscus.Methods Chondrocytes isolated from articular cartilage and meniscus of rabbits aged 3 weeks were respectively passaged in monolayer and cultured in centrifuge tube. Cartilages cultured in centrifuge tube and meniscus of rabbit aged 6 weeks were detected by histological examination and transmission electron microscopy. Growth curves of articular chondrocytes and meniscalfibrochondrocytes were compared; meanwhile, cell cycles of articular chondrocytes and meniscal fibrochondrocytes in passage 2and 4 were separately measured by flow cytometry.Results Articular chondrocytes in passage 4 were dedifferentiated. Articular chondrocytes formed cartilage 2 weeks after cultivation in centrifuge tube, but meniscal fibrochondrocytes could not generate cartilage. The differences in ultrastructure and histology obviously existed between cultured cartilage and meniscus; moreover, apoptosis of chondrocytes appeared in cultured cartilage. Proportion of subdiploid cells in articular chondrocytes passage 2 and 4 was markedly higher than that in passage 2 and 4 fibrochondrocytes(Plt;0.05). Conclusion Meniscal fibrochondrocytes can not form cartilage after cultivationin centrifuge tube, while cartilage cultured in centrifuge tube from articular chondrocytes can not be used as graft material for meniscus. Articular cartilage ismarkedly different from meniscus.
In order to observe the histological changes of the autogenous perichondrium graft from rib in the repair of injured articular cartilage of the condylar process of mandible, 50 rabbits were used, in which 15 were served as control. The articular cartilage with its subchondral bone were resected and an autogenous graft of costal perichondrium was sutured onto the raw surface of the condylar process, and in the controls, only the articular portion of the condylar process was resected without the application of autogenous costal perichondrium graft. The morphological changes of the newly formed cartilage during the process of its development were investigated by hiostological and autoradiog aphic techniques. The result revealed that 10 days after operation, the graft had increased in thickness and was richly populated form the proliferation of mesenchyme-like cells. Twenty to thirty days later, the chondrocytes were matured and the newly formed cartilage had covered the bony surface of mandibular condyle. At 60 days, the newly formed cartilagenous joint surface became glossy, and the morphology and arrangement of cells tended to be regular simulating the morphology of normal articular cartilage. From the experiment, it could be concluded that (1) The autogenous perichondrium graft placed on the condylar surface of mandible could form new articular cartilage which was similar in tissue morphology to the normal condylar cartilage. (2) The process of development of newly formed cartilage was similar to that of the normal cartilage. (3) The motion and loading on the joint could promote the formation of new cartilage and undergo biological reformation, gradually resulting in normal joint morphology. On this basis, the clinical application of autogenous perichondrium graft to repair injured cartilage of the condylar process of the mandible was feasible.
In order to investigate the effect of motion on repairing articular cartilage defect following autogenous periosteal graft, sixty adult rabbits were divided randomly into three groups: out-cage motion (OCM), in-cage motion (ICM) and immobilization (IMM). A defect of the articular cartilage, 1 cm x 0.5 cm in size, was made in the patellar-groove of femur of each hind limb. Free autogenous periosteal graft from the proximal tibia was sutured on the base of the left defect, while the right limb was served as control. The animals were sacrificed at 4, 8 and 12 weeks, respectively, after operation. The regeneration of the cartilage implanted was observed through gross, histology, histochemical assay and electronic microscope. The influence of different amount of motion on the chondrogenesis from the periosteal implant was also compared. The result showed that the hyaline cartilage produced from periosteal implant could be capable to repair full-thickness of articular cartilage. From statistical study, there was significant difference between OCM and ICM groups (P lt; 0.05), ICM and IMM (P lt; 0.05) as well as OCM and IMM (P lt; 0.01). It was suggested that the periosteal graft was effective in repair of defect of articular cartilage and the amount of motion was important for chondrogenesis.
Objective Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) can enhance the chondrocyte prol iferation and repair of cartilage defects. To explore the safety and efficacy of intra-knee-articular injection of PRP to treat knee articular cartilage degeneration by comparing with injecting sodium hyaluronate (SH). Methods Thirty consecutive patients (30 knees) with knee articular cartilage degeneration were selected between January 2010 and June 2010. According to different injections, 30 patients wererandomly divided into PRP group (test group, n=15) and SH group (control group, n=15). There was no significant difference in gender, age, body mass index, and Kellgren-Lawrence grade between 2 groups (P gt; 0.05). Test group received 3.5 mL of PRP intra-knee-articular injections while control group received 2 mL of SH during the same time period. Both treatments were administered in series of 3 intra-knee-articular injections at 3-week intervals. Then, adverse reactions were recorded. International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) score, Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC) score, and Lequesne index were used for evaluation of treatment results. Results The patients of 2 groups were followed up 6 months. There were significant differences in IKDC score, WOMAC score, and Lequesne index between pre- and post-injection in 2 groups (P lt; 0.05); no significant difference was found between different time points (3, 4, and 6 months) in test group (P gt; 0.05), while significant differences were found between the postoperative 6th month and the postoperative 3rd and 4th months in control group (P lt; 0.05). There was no significant difference in IKDC score, WOMAC score, and Lequesne index between 2 groups within 4 months (P gt; 0.05), but the effectiveness of test group was significantly better than that of control group at 6 months after injection (P lt; 0.05). Adverse reactions occurred in 12 patients (31 injections) of test group and in 12 patients (30 injections) of control group. No significant difference in onset time, termination time, and duration of adverse reactions were found between 2 groups (P gt; 0.05). Conclusion Intra-knee-articular injection of PRP to treat knee articular cartilage degeneration is safe, which can alleviate symptoms of pain and swell ing and improve the qual ity of l ife of patients; however, further data of large samples and long-term follow-up are needed to confirm the safety and effectiveness.
Objective To observe the long-term clinical results of repairing large articular cartilage defects of the hip and the knee with free autogeneous periosteum. Methods Based on the results of experimental studies, the authors used free autogeneous periosteum transplantation and postoperative continuous passive motion (CPM) to repair large articular cartilaginous defects in 52 patientsfrom February 1987 to August 1995. Of 37 patients with complete follow-up data, 16 had congenital dislocation of the hip, 6traumatic arthritis of hip, 1 femoral head destruction following mild infection, 2 ankylosing spondylitis, 6 intra-articular fracture of the knee, 4 arthritisof the knee and 2 stiff knee following joint infection. The patients with dislocation of hip were given relieving traction before operation. The cartilages of pathological changes were excised to bleeding bone. The defects were repairedwith periosteum removing from tibia. CPM were immediately applied for 4-6 weeksand no bearing was allowed 6 months after discharge. The silicon membrane was taken out in the 6th month. Results Thirty-seven patients (17 males, 20 females) were followed up 7-15 years with an average of 10.5 years. The functional evaluation referred to joint pain degree，joint mobile range，daily activity and X-ray findings. The results were excellence in 11 patients , good in 18 patients , poor in 8 patients. Conclusion The method to repair articular cartilage defect with free autogeneous -periosteum is effective and may be applied clinically.