Core Outcome Set (COS) is an important approach to address problems in which the outcomes are inconsistent, non-essential and reporting biased in clinical researches. In order to ensure the standardization of the COS development process, the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials (COMET) has initiatively developed the Core Outcome Set-STAndards for Development (COS-STAD). The recommendation includes 11 minimum standards, involving 3 common key domains: the scope, the stakeholders, and the consensus process. The COS-STAD is used by COS developers for standardizing research design, determining the quality of the methodology to develop a COS. Based on the background and conditions of clinical practice and clinical trials in China, especially the characteristics of the development of Core Outcome Set of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM-COS), this paper interprets the recommendations of COS-STAD, providing a reference for the potential users of COS in China.
In 2007, the findings from clinical trials on stroke treatment have been both encouraging and disappointing. In order to interpret the challenges and opportunity in evidence-based stroke practice, we reviewed several major clinical trials in stroke that were published last year. It revealed that we should strengthen the evidence base for acute stroke care by conducting more high-quality randomized controlled trials and by increasing the energy, resources and manpower available for these trials.
Objective To assess the quality of reporting of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) related to traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) published in the Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine by CONSORT statement and Jadad scale. Methods We handsearched the Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine to identify TCM RCTs. The revised CONSORT statement and Jadad scale combined with self-established criteria were applied. Results A total of 57 RCTs were identified of which there were 17 TCM RCTs. Some items in CONSORT checklist were completely reported in all TCM RCTs, such as abstract, inclusion and exclusion criteria, intervention, randomization sequence generation, description of statistic method, description of baseline data, outcomes and estimation, and explain results. Compared with the previous findings, there were more trials in this study to report allocation concealment, randomization implementation, use of flow chart and appliance. Only 3 RCTs (17.6%) reported acknowledgements. One RCT did not describe syndrome type of TCM, and 4 RCTs (23.5%) carried out dummy. The mean Jadad score was 4.35±1.11 in all trials, of which 11 RCTs (64.7) ranked 5 points. Conclusion The comprehensive quality of reporting of TCM RCTs published in the Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine from 2001 to 2008 has been improved. After the publication of CONSORT statement and CONSORT for traditional Chinese medicine, the quality of reporting of TCM RCTs is improved. We are looking forward to improving the CONSORT for TCM.
ObjectiveTo analyze the research status of mini-clinical evaluation exercise (Mini-CEX) in medical and nursing education in the mainland of China, so as to provide a basis for optimizing medical and nursing teaching evaluation tools and promoting the reform of medical and nursing personnel training mode.MethodsPubMed, Embase, Wanfang, CQVIP, China National Knowledge Infrastructure, and China Biomedical Literature Database were searched. The key words were “mini-clinical evaluation exercise” or “mini-CEX” or “CEX” or “mini clinical exercise evaluation”. The languages were limited to Chinese and English. The address of the first author was in the mainland of China. The retrieval time was from the establishment of the databases to December 31st, 2020. The literature was analyzed bibliometrically after screening and duplicate removal.ResultsA total of 536 articles were included for analysis and summary. The articles originated from 28 provincial-level administrative divisions in China, among which Shanghai, Xinjiang, Guangxi, Liaoning, and Guangdong were the top five in terms of the number of papers published. The annual number of papers published exceeded 60 in 2017, and reached 112 in 2019 and 113 in 2020, respectively. A total of 397 hospitals and universities contributed to the literature, among which 49 institutions published more than 2 papers. The maximum number of articles published by a same author was 5. There were 530 journal papers published in 169 journals. Only 228 articles (42.54%) were supported by funds, and the research type was mainly experimental and quasi experimental research (56.71%). Under the key words co-occurrence network analysis, a total of 321 nodes and 1 013 connections were obtained, with an average of 3.21 connections per node. In addition to “mini-CEX” and “mini-clinical exercise evaluation”, the most prominent research directions were “clinical teaching” “standardized training” “resident” “scenario simulation” and “clinical ability”.ConclusionsThe number of mini-CEX-related medical and nursing articles is increasing year by year, but the distribution of research areas and institutions is uneven, the research quality needs to be improved, the application scope and research types need to be enriched, and the research content needs to be expanded. In the future, teachers and research teams of medical colleges and universities should be mobilized to apply Mini-CEX teaching method to the cultivation of medical and nursing talents in a whole and continuous way, so as to further standardize the localization application of mini-CEX in the mainland of China, and promote the in-depth development of formative evaluation of medical education.
This article introduces a dynamical stratified blocked randomized algorithm when the static stratified blocked randomized algorithm is not suitable to resolve the problem caused by uncertain stratified factors and levels during calculation of the sample size at the stage of clinical trial design. Prior to the start of the clinical trial, a list of random numbers is created by blocked randomized algorithm. During field implementation, a block of random numbers is dynamically allocated to a stratify level. Thereafter, a subject is randomized into different groups in that block. The study of Chinese medicine for gastric cancer anemia and blood hypercoagulability is used as an example to illustrate how to design and implement dynamic stratified block randomized algorithm. The results show that the dynamic stratified block randomized algorithm is more flexible and adaptable than the static stratified blocked randomized algorithm. However, its application is more complex and requires higher standards in clinical trials.
Objective To analyze the current research status, characteristics and development trends of traditional medicine-related clinical trials registration, and to provide ideas and directions for further development of traditional medicine clinical trials. Methods The International Traditional Medicine Clinical Trial Registry (ITMCTR) database was searched by computer from inception to June 30, 2024, with unlimited trial registration status, to collect all the clinical trials on traditional medicine, and analyze the basic information of the trials, the diseases studied and the interventions. Results A total of 4 349 clinical trials related to traditional medicine were included, with the number of registrations peaking in the second half of 2020, and showing a steady upward trend after 2023. The trial sponsors of the study covered 9 countries and a total of 34 provinces/autonomous regions/municipalities in China, led by Beijing, Shanghai, Guangdong, Sichuan, and Zhejiang provinces, accounting for 69.72% of the total. The financial support for the studies was dominated by local government funds in various provinces and cities, accounting for 29.66%. Disease types studied were mainly circulatory system diseases, musculoskeletal system or connective tissue diseases, and tumor diseases, accounting for 29.91% of the total. A total of 3 751 (86.3%) clinical trials were interventional studies, of which randomized parallel control was predominant, and 213 large-sample studies with a sample size of more than 1 000 cases were included. A total of 20 types of interventions were involved, of which 1 114 (29.86%) clinical trials utilized oral prescription of herbal medicine interventions. Conclusion Clinical trial enrollment in traditional medicine has increased overall, but with significant geographic unevenness. Oral herbal soup/granule intervention studies are the mainstream hotspots. It is recommended to strengthen international cooperation, enrich the types of interventions, refine the trial design, and raise the awareness of researchers about the registration of high-quality traditional medicine clinical trials.
Objective To investigate inpatient disease constitution in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) Hospital of Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region from 2008 to 2010, in order to provide baseline data for medicine allocation of hospitals in western China and development of TCM hospitals. Methods A questionnaire combined with a subject interview was carried out, and the case records of inpatients from 2008 to 2010 were collected. The diseases in discharge records were classified according to International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10) based on the first diagnosis. Data including general information of the inpatients, discharge diagnosis etc. were rearranged and analyzed by Excel software. Results a) The top four systematic diseases seen commonly from 2008 to 2010 were as follows: circulatory system diseases, musculoskeletal system and connective tissue diseases, respiratory system diseases and digestive system diseases. The top four single diseases were hypertension, intervertebral disc disease, diabetes, bronchitis, emphysema and other chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases. Respiratory system diseases ranked the third in 2009 and 2010 from the fourth in 2008, and circulatory system diseases had ranked the first during the past three years; b) The following diseases as hypertension, bronchial emphysema and other chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases, diabetes, fractures, airway (bronchus, lung) cancer, and viral hepatitis were commonly seen in males rather than in females. By contrast, intervertebral disc disease, gallstone disease and cholecystitis, and anemia were commonly seen in females; and c) Hypertension was commonly seen in the aged above 60 years old; intervertebral disc disease mainly focused on the patients at the age of 15 to 59; and bronchial emphysema and other chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases, airway (bronchus, lung) cancer involved in the patients who were mostly over 60 years old. Conclusion a) The top four systematic diseases seen commonly from 2008to 2010 are as follows: circulatory system diseases, musculoskeletal system and connective tissue diseases, respiratory system diseases and digestive system diseases. The top four single diseases are hypertension, intervertebral disc disease, diabetes, bronchitis, emphysema and other chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases. So these diseases should be taken into well consideration when making development plans by hospital and complementing essential drugs list by local development; b) Chronic diseases become the main disease for troubling Xinjiang population; and c) Male and female are susceptible to different diseases which should be rationally avoided in order to prevent the induced occurrence.